Fetal gene therapy.

Fetal gene therapy was first proposed toward the end of the 1990s when the field of gene therapy was, to quote the Gartner hype cycle, at its "peak of inflated expectations." Gene therapy was still an immature field but over the ensuing decade, it matured and is now a clinical and market reality. The trajectory of treatment for several genetic diseases is toward earlier intervention. The ability, capacity, and the will to diagnose genetic disease early-in utero-improves day by day. A confluence of clinical trials now signposts a trajectory toward fetal gene therapy. In this review, we recount the history of fetal gene therapy in the context of the broader field, discuss advances in fetal surgery and diagnosis, and explore the full ambit of preclinical gene therapy for inherited metabolic disease.

Precarious hope: Ethical considerations for offering experimental fetal therapies outside of research after initial studies in humans.

OBJECTIVE: Risks and benefits of experimental fetal therapies can remain uncertain after initial clinical studies, especially long-term effects. Nevertheless, pregnant individuals may request them, hoping to benefit their future child. Guidance about offering experimental fetal therapies outside research (as "innovative therapy") is limited, despite their ethical complexity. We propose points for clinicians and reviewers to consider when deciding whether and how to offer experimental fetal therapies as innovative therapies after initial clinical studies. METHOD: We used conceptual analysis and a current case to develop points for consideration, grounded in broader debates on innovative therapy and the unique challenges associated with experimental fetal therapies. RESULTS: Clinicians should evaluate whether offering experimental fetal therapies as innovative therapy is appropriate for a pregnant individual and their fetus. The anticipated risk-benefit ratio for the fetus should be favorable. For the pregnant individual, risks may outweigh benefits, within reasonable limits. Medical resources should be sufficient to ensure appropriate care. Clinicians should support pregnant individuals in making informed choices. Clinicians offering innovative therapies with more than minimal risk should collect and report data on outcomes. Independent review should take place. CONCLUSION: Considering these points may advance the interests of fetuses, future children, and their families.

Neonatal Survival After Serial Amnioinfusions for Bilateral Renal Agenesis: The Renal Anhydramnios Fetal Therapy Trial.

Importance: Early anhydramnios during pregnancy, resulting from fetal bilateral renal agenesis, causes lethal pulmonary hypoplasia in neonates. Restoring amniotic fluid via serial amnioinfusions may promote lung development, enabling survival. Objective: To assess neonatal outcomes of serial amnioinfusions initiated before 26 weeks' gestation to mitigate lethal pulmonary hypoplasia. Design, Setting, and Participants: Prospective, nonrandomized clinical trial conducted at 9 US fetal therapy centers between December 2018 and July 2022. Outcomes are reported for 21 maternal-fetal pairs with confirmed anhydramnios due to isolated fetal bilateral renal agenesis without other identified congenital anomalies. Exposure: Enrolled participants initiated ultrasound-guided percutaneous amnioinfusions of isotonic fluid before 26 weeks' gestation, with frequency of infusions individualized to maintain normal amniotic fluid levels for gestational age. Main Outcomes and Measures: The primary end point was postnatal infant survival to 14 days of life or longer with dialysis access placement. Results: The trial was stopped early based on an interim analysis of 18 maternal-fetal pairs given concern about neonatal morbidity and mortality beyond the primary end point despite demonstration of the efficacy of the intervention. There were 17 live births (94%), with a median gestational age at delivery of 32 weeks, 4 days (IQR, 32-34 weeks). All participants delivered prior to 37 weeks' gestation. The primary outcome was achieved in 14 (82%) of 17 live-born infants (95% CI, 44%-99%). Factors associated with survival to the primary outcome included a higher number of amnioinfusions (P = .01), gestational age greater than 32 weeks (P = .005), and higher birth weight (P = .03). Only 6 (35%) of the 17 neonates born alive survived to hospital discharge while receiving peritoneal dialysis at a median age of 24 weeks of life (range, 12-32 weeks). Conclusions and Relevance: Serial amnioinfusions mitigated lethal pulmonary hypoplasia but were associated with preterm delivery. The lower rate of survival to discharge highlights the additional mortality burden independent of lung function. Additional long-term data are needed to fully characterize the outcomes in surviving neonates and assess the morbidity and mortality burden. Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT03101891.

Fetal Surgery for Myelomeningocele: Neurosurgical Perspectives.

More than 30 years have elapsed since it was recognised that folic acid supplementation could substantially reduce the risk of open neural tube defects (ONTDs). During that time, many countries have adopted policies of food fortification with demonstrable reduction in the incidence of both cranial and spinal ONTDs. Improved prenatal detection and termination has also resulted in a reduction in the number of affected live births. Nonetheless, in the USA about 1500 children, and in the UK around 500 children are born each year with myelomeningocele (MMC) and so the management of MMC and its complications continues to constitute a significant clinical workload for many paediatric neurosurgical units around the world.Until recently, the options available following antenatal diagnosis of MMC were termination of pregnancy or postnatal repair. As a result of the MOMS trial, prenatal repair has become an additional option in selected cases (Adzick et al., N Engl J Med 364(11):993-1004, 2011). Fetal surgery for myelomeningocele is now offered in more than 30 centres worldwide. The aim of this chapter is to review the experimental basis of prenatal repair of MMC, to critically evaluate the neurosurgical implications of this intervention and to describe the technique of 'open' repair, comparing this with emerging minimally invasive alternatives.

Myelomeningocele: the evolution of care over the last 50 years.

PURPOSE: Myelomeningocele (MMC) is one of the representative anomalies in the field of pediatric neurosurgery. During the 50 years of ISPN history, MMC had a tremendous changes in its incidence, clinical management and outcome with advanced understanding of its pathogenesis. We reviewed the changes in MMC during the period. METHODS: We reviewed the literature review and collected our experiences. RESULTS: During the 50 years, major changes happened in many aspects of MMC including incidence, pathoembryogenesis, folate deficiency, prevention, prenatal diagnosis, mode of delivery, treatment policy with ethical considerations, clinical treatment including fetal surgery, latex allergy, retethering, management outcome, multidisciplinary team approach, and socioeconomic and family issues. CONCLUSIONS: There was a great advance in the management and research of MMC during the 50 years. It is a monumental achievement of pediatric neurosurgeons and colleagues of the related fields.

Creation of a novel synthetic amniotic fluid for use in fetal therapy with in vitro testing on human amniotic membranes.

BACKGROUND: Normal saline or lactated Ringer's solutions are usually infused at the time of fetal interventions; however, the effect of these fluids on the amniotic membranes has never been assessed. Given both the significant differences between the composition of normal saline solution, lactated Ringer's solution, and amniotic fluid and the significant risk of prematurity after fetal interventions, an investigation is warranted. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to evaluate the effect of current amnioinfusion fluids on the human amnion compared with a novel synthetic amniotic fluid. STUDY DESIGN: Amniotic epithelial cells from term placentas were isolated and cultured per protocol. A synthetic amniotic fluid was created with similar electrolyte, pH, albumin, and glucose concentrations to human amniotic fluid, termed "Amnio-well." The cultured human amniotic epithelium was exposed to normal saline solution, lactated Ringer's solution, and Amnio-well. As a control, 1 group of cells remained in culture media. Cells were evaluated for apoptosis and necrosis. A second analysis to examine if cells could be "rescued" was performed, wherein the cells were allowed to remain in the culture media for an additional 48 hours after amnioinfusion. Subsequently, tissue testing with human amniotic membrane explants was evaluated similarly. Immunofluorescent intensity studies were undertaken to evaluate reactive oxygen species-mediated cell damage. Real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction was used to evaluate gene expression in apoptotic pathways. RESULTS: With simulated amnioinfusion, 44%, 52%, and 89% of amniotic epithelial cells were alive after exposure to normal saline solution, lactated Ringer's solution, and Amnio-well, respectively, compared with 85% in control (P<.001). After amnioinfusion and attempted cell rescue, 21%, 44%, 94%, and 88% of cells were alive after exposure to normal saline solution, lactated Ringer's solution, Amnio-well, and control, respectively (P<.001). In simulated amnioinfusion with full-thickness tissue explants, 68%, 80%, 93%, and 96% of cells were viable in normal saline solution, lactated Ringer's solution, Amnio-well, and control, respectively (P<.001). In culture, reactive oxygen species production was higher in normal saline solution, lactated Ringer's solution, and Amnio-well than in control (4.9-, 6.6-, and 1.8-fold higher, respectively, P<.001); however, this could be mitigated in Amnio-well by adding ulin-A-statin and ascorbic acid. Gene expression data revealed abnormal signaling in the p21 and BCL2/BAX pathways with normal saline solution compared with control (P=.006 and P=.041); changes were not seen with Amnio-well. CONCLUSION: In vitro, normal saline and lactated Ringer's solutions caused increased amniotic membrane reactive oxygen species and cell death. The use of a novel fluid similar to human amniotic fluid led to the normalization of cellular signaling and less cell death.

Indications, Resource Allocation, and Outcomes Associated with Ex-Utero Intrapartum Treatment Procedures: A North American Fetal Therapy Network Survey.

INTRODUCTION: Neonates with cardiorespiratory compromise at delivery are at substantial risk of hypoxic neurologic injury and death. Though mitigation strategies such as ex-utero intrapartum treatment (EXIT) exist, the competing interests of neonatal beneficence, maternal non-maleficence, and just distribution of resources require consideration. Due to the rarity of these entities, there are few systematic data to guide evidence-based standards. This multi-institutional, interdisciplinary approach aims to elucidate the current scope of diagnoses that might be considered for such treatments and examine if treatment allocation and/or outcomes could be improved. METHODS: After IRB approval, a survey investigating diagnoses appropriate for EXIT consultation and procedure, variables within each diagnosis, occurrence of maternal and neonatal adverse outcomes, and instances of suboptimal resource allocation in the last decade was sent to all North American Fetal Treatment Network center representatives. One response was recorded per center. RESULTS: We received a 91% response rate and all but one center offer EXIT. Most centers (34/40, 85%) performed 1-5 EXIT consultations per year and 17/40 (42.5%) centers performed 1-5 EXIT procedures in the last 10 years. The diagnoses with the highest degree of agreement between centers surveyed to justify consultation for EXIT are head and neck mass (100%), congenital high airway obstruction (90%), and craniofacial skeletal conditions (82.5%). Maternal adverse outcomes were noted in 7.5% of centers while neonatal adverse outcomes in 27.5%. A large percentage of centers report cases of suboptimal selection for risk mitigation procedures and several centers experienced adverse neonatal and maternal outcomes. CONCLUSION: This study captures the scope of EXIT indications and is the first to demonstrate the mismatch in resource allocation for this population. Further, it reports on attributable adverse outcomes. Given suboptimal allocation and adverse outcomes, further examination of indications, outcomes, and resource use is justified to drive evidence-based protocols.

Maternal-fetal surgery as part of pediatric palliative care.

Maternal-fetal surgical interventions have become a more common part of prenatal care. This third option, beside termination or post-natal interventions, complicates prenatal decision-making: while interventions may be lifesaving, survivors may face a life with disability. Pediatric palliative care (PPC) is more than end of life or hospice care, it aims at helping patients with complex medical conditions live well. In this paper, we briefly discuss maternal-fetal surgery, challenges regarding counseling and benefit-risk evaluation, argue that PPC should be a routine part of prenatal consultation, discuss the pivotal role of the maternal-fetal surgeon in the PCC-team, and finally discuss some of the ethical considerations of maternal-fetal surgery. We illustrate this with a case example of an infant diagnosed with congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH).

Legal Discrepancies and Expectations of Women: Abortion, Fetal Therapy, and NICU Care.

Over the past several decades in which access to abortion has become increasingly restricted, parents' autonomy in medical decision-making in the realms of fetal care and neonatal intensive care has expanded. Today, parents can decide against invasive medical interventions at gestational ages where abortions are forbidden, even in cases where neonates are expected to be seriously ill. Although a declared state interest in protecting the lives of fetuses and newborns contributes to justifications for restricting women's autonomy with regards to abortion, it does not fully explain this discrepancy. We believe that social portrayals of women as complying with or shirking their reproductive function play a major role in explaining it. The growing divide between a woman's rights as a reproductive being and as a parent suggest that abortion restriction is rooted in a historical societal desire for women to serve as reproducers and in the corresponding fear of them abandoning this allotted role in pursuit of social equality. The Dobbs v. Jackson (2022) decision is not based in a view of abortion as a medical act occurring between a doctor and patient, as Roe v. Wade (1973) did, but decision-making about fetal therapy or NICU care is still viewed as occurring between a doctor and patient or surrogate because in this act a woman is seen as fulfilling her role as mother.

International Society for Prenatal Diagnosis 2022 DEBATE: There should be formal accreditation and ongoing quality assurance/review for units offering fetal therapy that includes public reporting of outcomes.

The field of fetal therapy has so far escaped from formal accreditation and quality control. Despite that, current published evidence shows that outcomes of interventions in younger fetal therapy centers are similar to what is achieved in more experienced centers and outcomes of interventions have improved over time. The question however remains what is not being published and what should be the standard of care, given the lack of level 1 evidence from randomized controlled trials for many interventions. Formal collaborative networks such as NAFTnet and others allow for anonymized benchmarking of center outcomes, without publicly shaming (and financially punishing) underperforming centers. Large registries also allow for tracking of rare complications and may result in improved patient outcomes over time. Core outcome sets, which could serve as a basis for outcome reporting, are available for some conditions, but certainly not for all, resulting in communication difficulties between centers. Formal accreditation, quality control, and outcome reporting are hard to implement, expensive, and may result in decreasing access to care by pushing smaller centers out of the market. Despite the existing difficulties, international societies have committed to quality improvement, and fetal therapy programs are strongly recommended to participate in voluntary outcome tracking.

The Rearing of Maternal-Fetal Surgery: The Maturation of a Field from Conception to Adulthood.

Maternal-fetal surgery is fraught with inherent controversy from within the medical community and general public. Despite these challenges, the field of maternal-fetal surgery evolved into an international enterprise. Carefully nurtured by pioneers with foresight and resilience, the field navigated ethical dilemmas with rigorous scientific methodology, collaboration, transparency, and accordance. These central pillars are consistent throughout the brief but momentous history of maternal-fetal surgery, serving as the catalyst for its success. The maturation of fetal intervention is an exemplar of technological innovation propelling clinical innovation, as well as a celebration of mastering the delicate balance between caution and optimism.

Molecular and Cellular In Utero Therapy.

Significant advances in maternal-fetal medicine and gene sequencing technology have fostered a new frontier of in utero molecular and cellular therapeutics, including gene editing, enzyme replacement therapy, and stem cell transplantation to treat single-gene disorders with limited postnatal treatment strategies. In utero therapies take advantage of unique developmental properties of the fetus to allow for the correction of monogenic disorders before irreversible disease pathology develops. While early preclinical studies in animal models are encouraging, more studies are needed to further evaluate their safety and efficacy prior to widespread clinical use.

Fetal Repair of Neural Tube Defects.

Myelomeningocele is the most common congenital neurologic defect, and the only nonlethal disease addressed by fetal surgery. A randomized control trial has established amelioration of the Arnold-Chiari II malformation, reduced ventriculoperitoneal shunt rate, and improvement in distal neurologic function in patients that receive in utero repair. Long-term follow-up of these school-age children demonstrates the persistence of these effects. The use of stem cells in fetal repair is being investigated to further improve distal motor function.

Fetal Therapy for Renal Anhydramnios.

The most severe forms of congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract present in fetal life with early pregnancy renal anhydramnios and are considered lethal due to pulmonary hypoplasia without fetal therapy. Due to the high rate of additional structural anomalies, genetic abnormalities, and associated syndromes, detailed anatomic survey and genetic testing are imperative when stratifying which pregnancies are appropriate for fetal intervention. Restoring amniotic fluid around the fetus is the principal goal of prenatal treatment. The ongoing multi-center Renal Anhydramnios Fetal Therapy (RAFT) trial is assessing the safety and efficacy of serial amnioinfusions to prevent pulmonary hypoplasia so that the underlying renal disease can be addressed.

In Utero Therapy for Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia.

Congenital diaphragmatic hernia is an anomaly that is often prenatally diagnosed and spans a wide spectrum of disease, with high morbidity and mortality associated with fetuses with severe defects. Congenital diaphragmatic hernia is thus an ideal target for fetal intervention. We review the literature on prenatal diagnosis, describe the history of fetal intervention for congenital diaphragmatic hernia, and discuss fetal endoscopic tracheal occlusion and the Tracheal Occlusion To Accelerate Lung growth trial results. Finally, we present preclinical studies for potential future directions.